Does ‘Ebenezer’ Have Too Much Baggage to Deliver the Christmas Cheer?

Leave a comment

A real Humbug-dinger? (CREDIT: Paramount Pictures)

Starring: Johnny Depp, Rupert Grint, Andrea Riseborough, Tramell Tillman, Robert Strange, Daisy Ridley, Ian McKellen, Sam Claflin, Arthur Conti, Ellie Bamber, Nicholas Day, Charlie Murphy, Henry Lloyd-Hughes

Director: Ti West

Running Time: 116 Minutes

Rating: PG-13 for Spooky Specters

Release Date: November 13, 2026 (Theaters)

What’s It About?: You know that crotchety old businessman Ebenezer? He’s quite the scrooge, isn’t he? In fact, he’s the namesake for a grumpy and stingy person of the anti-Christmas persuasion. He was introduced to us by Charles Dickens in the 1843 novella A Christmas Carol, which has been adapted pretty much endlessly in the 200 years since. In the 2026 movie Ebenezer, Johnny Depp takes up the cane of the title character, as he goes on his usual Christmas Eve adventure of three ghosts showing him the error of his ways, with his late partner Jacob Marley (Ian McKellen), employee Bob Cratchit (Rupert Grint), and nephew Fred (Sam Claflin) also doing their parts to help him see the light.

What Made an Impression?: How Depp is Your Love?: Ebenezer‘s marketing has positioned itself as Johnny Depp’s reintroduction to the highest echelons of movie stardom. In the past decade or so, he’s been more famous for his personal troubles (particularly those related to accusations of spousal abuse) than any character he’s played. He has appeared in other recent movies, but this is definitely the most high-profile one since 2018. I have mixed feelings about Depp trying to make a comeback. He was never my favorite actor, but he’s definitely given some performances I’ve loved. So I can’t really watch this movie without feeling conflicted, although ultimately even if this part were played by an oddball without any baggage, it would still feel tepid. The character design is more garish than most Scrooges, for sure, but emotionally it’s pretty straightforward, especially by Depp’s standards. It’s more than adequate, but not much more.
Where’s the Caroling?: The fact that this flick is named after its main character instead of the book it’s based on might lead you to wonder if this version explores Scrooge’s backstory more than usual. But that origin is already baked into the visit from the Ghost of Christmas Past (a notably spooky Andrea Riseborough). So, yeah, this is more or less the same old Christmas Carol that so many of us revisit this time every year. (If we get any more of any significance from any character, it’s probably Marley.) Ebenezer has always been right at the center of his own story. In conclusion, there’s nothing particularly new here, except maybe the production design.
Hi, Ti: While I felt uneasy about Ebenezer‘s Ebenezer, I was intrigued by its director, as Ti West is the helmer behind the X trilogy, one of my favorite horror series of this century. So I wondered if he might accordingly deliver a more frightening sensibility. The verdict in that regard is that he certainly does, although not overwhelmingly so. There’s a striking body horror approach with the Ghost of Christmas Present (Tramell Tillman), and in the most emotionally intense moments, it feels like the set is going to be overwhelmed by pure blackness. But the gentleness at the core of the story remains resolute. Maybe West just wanted to show us his gooier side. And if that was his goal, it helps that the most memorable characters are the incessantly optimistic Fred and his lovely wife Clara (Daisy Ridley), who don’t always get their fair showcase in Christmas Carol adaptations. But they do here, so don’t ever give up on your family, I guess

Ebenezer is Recommended If You Like: It when the holiday season make you feel conflicted

Grade: 3 out of 5 Humbugs

Hey, ‘The Christophers,’ I Wonder What’s Going on With You Guys

Leave a comment

Not Pictured: The Christophers (CREDIT: NEON/Screenshot)

Starring: Michaela Coel, Ian McKellen, James Corden, Jessica Gunning

Director: Steven Soderbergh

Running Time: 100 Minutes

Rating: R

Release Date: April 10, 2026 (Theaters)

Here and there, I occasionally assess a movie I’ve seen by asking, “Would I like this to be my life?” Whenever the movie in question takes place in the art world, the answer is almost invariably “No!” So that’s not a good sign for The Christophers, in which Michaela Coel plays a young artist who is hired to sneakily complete a series of unfinished paintings by an aging artist played by Ian McKellen. But this tale actually takes place on the fringes of the art world and toys with the notions that govern it. So I’m saying that despite my built-in skepticism,  there’s some fun to be had along the way. Also, there’s this one part with an art-based reality show that looks pretty awful, but in a kind of subversive way. So no, I don’t want to live the life of The Christophers, but I suspect that the people who made this movie don’t want me to either.

Grade: 5.5 Forgeries out of 8 Christophers

‘Cats’ is a Jellicle-Only Affair

1 Comment

CREDIT: Universal Pictures

Starring: Francesca Hayward, James Corden, Judi Dench, Jason Derulo, Idris Elba, Jennifer Hudson, Ian McKellen, Taylor Swift, Rebel Wilson, Ray Winstone

Director: Tom Hooper

Running Time: 110 Minutes

Rating: PG for CGI’d Cat-People Lifting Their Legs Up Suggestively

Release Date: December 20, 2019

I admire the people who have made Cats, including all versions of the musical and this here film adaptation. The whole premise is thoroughly ridiculous, and all the little details only make it more so. So anyone who has given it their all at the Jellicle Ball has no time for the shame that such an enterprise might convey. That sort of pluck and resilience will get you far in life. It doesn’t necessarily make for good filmmaking, though. In this case, at least, it just transfers something truly baffling in one iteration into something just as baffling, in the same ways and more, in another medium.

The plot, such as it is, is immensely inconsequential, but it has something to do with new cat in town Victoria (Francesca Hayward) trying to find her place in cat society while devious cat Macavity (Idris Elba) plucks away his competition for the Jellicle Ball, which I’m pretty sure is some sort of talent show. Meanwhile, all the other cats prance about and sing their signature songs to let us know who they are. So far, so phantasmagorical. This could be appreciated as a bizarre theatrical extravaganza if the staging and choreography were decent. But director Tom Hooper has a way of shooting every scene that makes it feel like everything is so far away, even the close-ups. It confers an elusive nature that is the opposite of the extreme intimacy of high-frame rate, and thus it is difficult to connect with whatever emotional resonance the actors are able to summon. If something is going to be as unbelievable as this, it ought to also be unforgettable. Alas, Cats is just a piffle that my subconscious doesn’t even want to bother with.

Cats is Recommended If You Like: Thorough nonsense

Grade: 2 out of 5 Jellicles

In ‘The Good Liar,’ Ian McKellen and Helen Mirren Bring Their Own Violent Spin to the Con Artist Game

1 Comment

CREDIT: Warner Bros.

Starring: Ian McKellen, Helen Mirren, Russell Tovey, Jim Carter

Director: Bill Condon

Running Time: 110 Minutes

Rating: R for Shocking Old Person-on-Old Person Violence and a Quick Walk Through a Strip Club

Release Date: November 15, 2019

As Ian McKellen meets up with Helen Mirren for a first date and they complain about the “computer service” and its supposed reputation for “mismatching the delusional with the hopeless,” it’s a good bet that The Good Liar isn’t just a simple septua/octogenarian rom-com. Even if you didn’t know going in that this was a thriller, the smoking hot, fine-tuned wit would tip you off that something deeper and more sinister, is going on. And sure enough, as Ray Courtnay (McKellen) and Betty McLeish (Mirren) continue going out together, Ray is also busy with his business partner Vincent (Jim Carter) on a grift worth hundreds of thousands of dollars. You very quickly get the sense that pretty much everyone in Ray’s life is a target of his cons, and each act in the film gives a new clue of the lifelong layers of his false identities. All of this should seemingly have us very worried for Betty.

But if you are like me, you were never seriously concerned that she would be the ultimate victim, considering that she is played by the indomitable Helen Mirren and con artist films so often turn on a reversal of fortune. So the fact that Betty pulls one over on the most frighteningly masterful deceiver should come as no shock. The joy is in the details of beholding her playing her part so perfectly and the final revelation of just why she is the one who would want to turn the tables (a date to see Inglourious Basterds is an early hint). No punches are pulled as we learn the truth, which transcends just Ray and Betty’s story and touches upon all of Europe reckoning with its violent past. Ray is the kind of man who doesn’t think twice about killing someone to protect himself and then slip away undetected. Betty’s story is about ensuring that all-too-common terrible legacy finally catches up to him.

And as one last important note, I must mention the tablets that Ray and Vincent use to transfer funds in the deployment of their grifts. These things are hilariously bulky, looking more like giant calculators (with conveniently large-print text for the senior set) instead of any familiar twenty-first century gizmo. Perhaps these really are what people with bank accounts worth millions of dollars actually do use to make convenient transfers at home and on the go. And it’s not like there was ever any way to make pushing buttons on these tablets look particularly cinematic. Honestly, though, I’m not complaining. It’s not like these moments demand to be visually seamless. These tablets certainly aren’t part of the mental picture I have for big-time con artists, but I often enjoy it when my expectations are confounded.

The Good Liar is Recommended If You Like: Dirty Rotten Scoundrels, The Remains of the Day, The Debt

Grade: 3.75 out of 5 False Identities

This Is a Movie Review Review: Beauty and the Beast (2017)

1 Comment

What up with Disney ransacking its vault to remake its own animated hits into (mostly[-ish]) live-action versions? This is not an inherently bad idea. These are stories that have been told over and over (often in fairy tale form) and will continue to be told over and over, so why not spruce them up with some 21st Century Pizzazz?

What does new-flavor Beauty and the Beast offer over the 1991 toon? Belle’s an inventor, but that does not factor in too much. There is an “exclusively gay moment” for Le Fou, but it is so inconsequential that you might need a study guide to locate it (I certainly did). So ultimately, this is about some legends of acting and singing giving it a whirl. Nothing earth-shattering, but we’re in good hands.

I give Beauty and the Beast 3 Rose Petals out of 5 Snowy Days in June.